Jaye can't sleep and so heads to the bar where Eric is closing up.  She learns that he sleeps in the back and they both find a woman in a barrel inside the bar.  A penguin tells Jaye to "get her back" and so they try to do so.  They eventually discover that she is a nun trying to leave her abbey and the priest has come to get her back.  Jaye tries to restore her faith in order to "get her back" but she is not fully convinced that she is not pulling one over on her.  The priest is later pulled over for a busted taillight that Jaye was told to break and he's taken to jail.  He learns that he has a daughter and get to meet her.  Seeing this convinces the nun that Jaye must have gotten a message that she disbelieved earlier and she returns to the abbey.  The priest ends up quitting the order in order to see his daughter.